The Lesson That Didn’t Go as Planned

In partnership with

I had a plan.

It was a good plan.
It was calm, reasonable, and grounded in the belief that I was about to teach something useful.

This should have been my first warning.

The goal was simple: a quiet, focused training session. Five minutes. Maybe ten. Just enough to reinforce a few basics and end on a win. I had treats. I had time. I had optimism — which, in hindsight, was the real mistake.

Biscuit arrived first.

“I will be leading this,” she announced, climbing onto the mat I had just laid out. “I have already assessed the situation.”

I had not invited an assessment.

Kevin followed immediately behind her, sat down with great care, and whispered, “Is this a meeting?”

“No,” I said. “This is training.”

Kevin nodded. “Okay. I am ready for training meeting.”

Cricket did not sit. She stood off to the side, watching. Waiting. Evaluating. I could feel the math happening behind her eyes.

“Today,” I said, “we’re going to work on focus.”

Biscuit tilted her head. “Focus on what.”

“On me,” I said.

She considered this. “That seems inefficient.”

I ignored that and asked for a sit.

Kevin sat so hard he nearly tipped forward. Biscuit sat sideways, already scanning the room. Cricket did not sit at all.

“I am focused,” Biscuit said. “On the window, the door, and the possibility that something interesting could happen behind me.”

Cricket finally spoke. “Statistically speaking,” she said, “nothing interesting has happened during training in the last twelve sessions.”

“That’s because you’re not paying attention,” Biscuit replied.

I asked for a down.

Kevin collapsed like a sack of laundry. Biscuit lowered herself slowly, maintaining eye contact with me as if this were a negotiation. Cricket lay down only after I repeated the cue — because, as she later explained, “You didn’t say it with enough clarity the first time.”

This was minute two.

I tried again. Sit. Treat. Down. Treat. Stay.

“Stay how long?” Biscuit asked.

“Just a moment,” I said.

“A moment is not a unit of time,” she replied. “This lacks structure.”

Kevin, misunderstanding entirely, stayed very still and whispered, “I am staying forever.”

Cricket broke her stay to correct him. “That’s not what he means.”

“Well now I’m confused,” Kevin said, standing up. “Do I stay or not stay?”

No one was staying.

I took a breath. Reset. Calm energy.

“Okay,” I said. “Let’s try something else.”

Biscuit brightened immediately. “New plan. Excellent.”

I asked for eye contact.

Kevin stared into my soul. Biscuit glanced at me briefly, then returned to monitoring the room. Cricket made eye contact, blinked once, and looked away — because technically she had complied.

“That counts,” she said.

At this point, I realized the lesson I thought I was teaching — focus, patience, cooperation — was not the lesson actually happening.

The dogs were not learning to listen better.

They were learning exactly how predictable I was.

Biscuit had figured out when treats appeared. Kevin had learned that enthusiasm was always rewarded, regardless of accuracy. Cricket had confirmed that precision mattered more than speed, and that interruptions would eventually lead to clarification.

And me?

I was learning that training does not happen in straight lines. It happens sideways. Through misunderstanding. Through negotiation. Through moments where nothing goes according to plan, but everyone is still learning something.

I ended the session early.

“Good job,” I said, handing out final treats.

Biscuit nodded. “We will review your performance.”

Kevin wagged. “I liked the meeting.”

Cricket sighed, already moving on.

Later that evening, I thought about how often I decide a lesson should go one way — and how often real learning ignores that plan entirely. The dogs didn’t fail the session. They just taught a different lesson than the one I had prepared.

And maybe that’s how it’s supposed to work.

After all, if everything went exactly as planned, none of us would learn much at all.

Question: “Kevin, what do I do when my dog won’t focus during training and everything falls apart?”

Kevin answers:

Okay. First of all, I am very qualified for this question because I also do not focus during training.

Sometimes training starts, and I am doing great. I am sitting. I am staying. I am thinking about treats. This is productive.

But then my brain notices something else. A sound. A smell. A feeling. A thought about yesterday. Or tomorrow. Or the floor.

When that happens, the training does not fall apart. It just… becomes a different training.

I think when dogs don’t focus, it is not because they are being bad. It is because their brains are busy learning many things at once. Some of those things are not what you planned, but they are still important.

Also, sometimes it helps to stop. Or take a break. Or do something easier. Or say “good job” anyway, because trying is hard.

Cricket says this is called “adjusting expectations.”
Biscuit says this is called “negotiation.”

I think it is called doing your best.

— Kevin ✔️

If you want to see Biscuit “learning” healthy choices, you definitely want to see THIS video!

Before you go…

Cartoon of the Week!

And now a word from our sponsor:

What do these names have in common?

• Arnold Schwarzenegger

• Codie Sanchez

• Scott Galloway

• Colin & Samir

• Shaan Puri

• Jay Shetty

They all run their businesses on beehiiv. Newsletters, websites, digital products, and more. beehiiv is the only platform you need to take your content business to the next level.

🚨Limited time offer: Get 30% off your first 3 months on beehiiv. Just use code PLATFORM30 at checkout.

Start building for 30% off today.